Squishy Mystery
Packs
12 spooky designs. Endless surprises.
Soft, slow-rising squishies, sealed in wrappers. You don’t know which design you’ll get — that’s the fun.
The Halloween designs
Why the wrappers?
Every squishy stays sealed in its wrapper until it reaches you. It keeps them clean, fresh, and adds an extra layer of mystery.
The Spooky Stash · Halloween clearance
Pick your pack
Halloween is over, so the last of the Halloween squishies are marked down while they last. Add any multi-pack and the whole order ships free. Ships the next business day, 2–5 days by USPS.
+ $4.99 shipping — $17.99 $12.98 delivered
Free shipping
Free shipping
Full Case
Free shipping
Tax calculated at checkout. Secure payment on Stripe. Ages 14+.
Halloween is one batch.
When these are gone they are gone - the next run is a different season entirely. Leave your email and you will hear the moment it drops. Nothing else, ever.
Ready to squish?
Find your packFAQ
What designs are available?
Twelve Halloween designs: Sunset Bats, Wicked Green, Bat Signal, Boneyard Gold, Witching Hour, Crooked Tree, Grinning Jack, Haunted House, Plum Spooky, Cobweb Corner, Cotton Ghost and Dusk Pumpkin. You can see all twelve on the home page.
Can I choose my design?
No — and that’s deliberate. Every pack is pulled assorted. Your designs are assigned when you check out, and you’ll see exactly which ones you got on your confirmation page.
Can I receive duplicates?
Yes. Each squishy is drawn on its own, so a duplicate is possible in a larger pack. The full case gives you the widest spread.
Will the Halloween designs return?
The Halloween designs are a seasonal run. When they’re gone the next run will be a different design entirely, so the ones here won’t come back in this form.